Menupickcom lists publicly available information. We are not affiliated with the restaurants shown. How we source and check listings
Claim your listing

Menupickcom

Casa Vieja menu

9 dishes across 5 sections $20 to $30 Colombian Restaurant

Prices transcribed from the printed menu, last checked

Menu Casa Vieja photo menu 1
Photographed in store, August 2026. See all 4 pages

Photos of the printed menu

Photographed in store in August 2026. The dish list below covers everything we could read clearly; the full card has more.

Casa Vieja photo menu 1 Casa Vieja photo menu 2 Casa Vieja photo menu 3 Casa Vieja photo menu 4 Casa Vieja photo menu 5 Casa Vieja photo menu 6 Casa Vieja photo menu 7 Casa Vieja photo menu 8 Casa Vieja photo menu 9 Casa Vieja photo menu 10

Para Antes (appetizers) 17 dishes

  • El Maduro Con Queso Y Carne

    yellow plantain stuffed with cheese and meat

  • Las Papas Rellenas

    potato balls stuffed with meat

  • La Arepa Con Queso

    white corn griddle cake stuffed with cheese

  • El Aguacate Relleno

    avocado stuffed with shrimp in a special sauce

  • El Pincho

    grilled beef served on a skewer

  • Las Empanadas (orden De Tres)

    meat filled turnovers (order of three)

  • La Arepa De Chocolo

    yellow corn bread griddle cake topped with cheese

  • Las Quesadillas Con Chorizo O Champinones

    flour tortilla stuffed with cheese and choice of colombian sausage or mushrooms

  • Los Nachos

  • Con Pollo O Carne

    corn tortilla topped with cheese and choice of beef or chicken

  • Las Papas Con Queso

    potatoes topped with cheese, bacon and jalapeno peppers

  • El Mofongo

    mashed green plantain with garlic and fried pork rinds

  • El Guacamole

    a blend of avocado, freshly chopped vegetables and spices

  • Buffalo Wings

  • El Chicharon Con Arepa

    crisp fried pork rinds served with a griddle cake

  • El Chorizo Con Champinones

    colombian sausage served with a griddle cake or sauteed with mushrooms

  • El Chorizo Con Arepa

Sopas Del Dia (soup Of The Day) 2 dishes

  • Sopas Grande

    large soup of the day

  • Sopas Pequeno

    small soup of the day

Los Platos Tipicos (typical Dishes) 18 dishes

  • La Bandeja Paisa O Montanera

    carne asada o carne molida, huevo frito, chicharron, maduro y arepa (grilled steak, or ground beef, fried egg, fried pork rinds, sweet plantain and griddle cake)

  • El Lechon Cubano

    cuban style roast pork served with moros and cristianos and green plantain

  • La Bandeja Especial

    carne, lomo, pollo asado, huevo frito, chicharron, maduro y arepa (grilled steak, pork loin and chicken breast, fried egg, fried pork rinds, sweet plantain and griddle cake)

  • La Bandeja "casa Vieja"

    pechuga de pollo asada, arroz, frijoles negros y maduro (marinated grilled chicken breast, rice, black beans and yellow plantain).

  • El Bistec A Caballo

    grilled steak sauteed with onions, tomatoes and peppers topped with fried egg.

  • La Sobrebarriga A La Plancha O A La Criolla

    colombian flank steak grilled or creole style

  • El Churrasco Argentino

    grilled sirloin steak argentine style.

  • El Churrasco A La Pobre

    grilled sirloin steak chilean style topped with fried onions and fried egg.

  • La Milanesa

    breaded beef steak.

  • Lal Lengua En Salsa

    beef tongue cooked in chef's special sauce

  • El Lechon Asado

    roast pork served with rice, black beans and yellow plantain

  • El Sandwich Cubano

    roast pork, ham and cheese grilled sandwich

  • La Parrillada Argentina

    "typical argentine platter" grilled steak, chicken, pork and sausage platter

  • El Tamal

    corn meal stuffed with chicken, meat and vegetables wrapped in a plantain leaf

  • Los Tostones Con Todo - Pequeno

    platanos verdes con carne pollo, guacamole, ceviche, chicharrones (green plantain with beef, chicken, guacamole. ceviche and fried pork rinds)

  • Los Tostones Con Todo - Grande

    platanos verdes con carne pollo, guacamole, ceviche, chicharrones (green plantain with beef, chicken, guacamole. ceviche and fried pork rinds)

  • La Picada - Pequeno

    platter of assorted meats and fried tropical vegetables.

  • La Picada - Grande

    platter of assorted meats and fried tropical vegetables.

Las Carnes (meat Dishes) 13 dishes

  • La Chuleta De Pollo Empanizada

    breaded chicken cutlet

  • La Carne Asada

    grilled top round steak

  • La Carne Asada Con Arepa

    grilled top round steak served with a large griddle cake

  • La Carne Guisada

    grilled top round steak served with a large griddle cake

  • El Bistec A La Criolla O Encebollado

    top round steak creole style or sauteed with onions

  • Las Chuletas De Cerdo Asadas O Al Ajillo

    center cut pork chops grilled or with garlic sauce

  • Las Chuletas De Cerdo Empanizadas

    breaded loin of pork

  • El Lomo De Cerdo Asado

    grilled loin of pork

  • El Arroz Con Pollo

    chicken and rice

  • El Pollo Al Champinon

    chicken sauteed with mushrooms and hearts of artichokes

  • El Pollo Asado

    half roasted chicken

  • Taco Salad

  • Casa Vieja Wrap

Fajitas 4 dishes

  • Chicken Or Beef Fajitas

  • Chicken And Beef Fajitas

  • Shrimp Fajitas

  • Meat, Chicken And Shrimp Fajitas

Los Platos Frios (cold Dishes) 6 dishes

  • La Ensalada "casa Vieja"

    house mixed salad

  • El Coctel De Langostions

    shrimp cocktail

  • El Ceviche

    shrimp marinated in lime juice

  • La Ensalada De Pulpo

    octopus salad

  • La Ensalada De Aguacate

    avocado salad

  • El Ajiaco

    creamy chicken soup. el especial del domingo (sunday special)

Los Pescados Y Mariscos (fish And Seafood Dishes) 11 dishes

  • Los Camarones Al Ajillo

    shrimp sauteed in garlic sauce

  • Los Camarones Empanizados

    breaded fried shrimp

  • Camarones Encendidos (al Chipotle)

    shrimp in a special mexican sauce with yellow rice and black beans

  • La Picada De Mariscos - Pequeno

    platter of assorted fried seafood and tropical vegetables

  • La Picada De Mariscos - Grande

    platter of assorted fried seafood and tropical vegetables

  • El Pargo Rojo Frito O A La Criolla

    whole red snapper fried or creole style

  • La Cazuela A La Casa Vieja

    seafood casserole

  • Con Langosta

    with lobster

  • El Filete De Pescado Empanizado

  • El Arroz Con Camarones

    shrimp and rice

  • La Paella Marinera (para Uno-for One)

    seafood and rice

Para Machotes (mexican Specialties) 10 dishes

  • One Meat Taco, One Cheese Enchilada

  • Two Cheese Enchildas

  • One Cheese Burrito, One Meat Taco

  • Two Beef Tamales

  • One Bean Burrito, One Cheese Enchilada

  • One Guacamole Tostada, One Cheese Burrito

  • Two Chicken Enchiladas

  • Two Soft Tacos

  • Two Seafood Enchiladas

  • Any Three Items

Las Porciones (side Orders) 9 dishes

  • Arroz

    rice

  • Frijoles Rojos

    red beans

  • Las Papas Chorriadas

    potatoes in cheese sauce

  • El Aguacate

    avocado

  • Los Frijoles Negros

    black beans

  • El Arroz Con Gandules

    rice with pigeon peas

  • Las Papas Fritas

    french fries

  • La Yuca Frita

    fried cassava

  • Los Maduros O Tostones

    sweet or green fried plantain

About these prices

Restaurants change prices without notice, and a menu photographed in August may already be out of date. Treat these figures as a guide, not a quote. If you spot a difference, tell us and we will re-check it.

If you’re looking for an authentic Colombian dining experience in Brentwood, Casa Vieja is the spot to check out. Located at 1768 Brentwood Rd, Brentwood, NY 11717, this vibrant restaurant brings the flavors of Colombia right to your neighborhood. The moment you step in, you’ll notice the warm and inviting vibe that makes Casa Vieja more than just a place to eat-it’s a place to enjoy, relax, and savor each bite. Whether you’re craving comfort food classics, healthy options, or small plates to share, the menu has something for everyone. Their offerings include a range of drinks from wine and cocktails to coffee and beer, making it easy to pair your meal with just the right beverage. If you’re planning a casual night out or just need a quick bite, Casa Vieja has you covered with options like late-night food, happy hour deals, and quick bites. The private dining room is perfect for intimate gatherings, while the lively main dining area keeps the energy up for friends and family meals. Beyond the dine-in experience, Casa Vieja makes it easy to enjoy Colombian cuisine at home with delivery and takeout options, so you can satisfy your cravings whenever you like. From hard liquor to refreshing cocktails, every drink is crafted to complement the vibrant flavors of the food. Whether it’s a light lunch with a coffee, a relaxed dinner with wine, or a late-night snack after a long day, Casa Vieja offers flexibility without compromising quality. The friendly staff makes every visit feel personal, and the attention to detail in both service and presentation ensures that you’re treated to more than just a meal-you get an experience. With every dish designed to highlight authentic Colombian tastes and every drink served just right, it’s easy to see why locals love stopping by.

Other menus in Brentwood

Prices transcribed the same way, each with the date last checked.

All Brentwood listings
Call Menu Directions